Investigation of the required detector distance in array-based treatment plan verifications
Ann-Kathrin Stedem,
Germany
PO-1566
Abstract
Investigation of the required detector distance in array-based treatment plan verifications
Authors: Ann-Kathrin Stedem1, Johanna Quast1, Holger Gottschlag2, Andreas A Schönfeld3
1Heinrich-Heine-Universität Düsseldorf, Mathematisch-Naturwissenschaftliche Fakultät, Düsseldorf, Germany; 2Universitätsklinik Düsseldorf, Klinik für Strahlentherapie und Radioonkologie, Düsseldorf, Germany; 3Sun Nuclear Corporation, Research and Development, Melbourne, USA
Show Affiliations
Hide Affiliations
Purpose or Objective
The aim of the work was to determine the spatial
frequency content of small radiation fields and planar dose distributions
common in SRT, to ensure that the Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem is fulfilled
by detector arrays used for pre-treatment patient specific quality assurance.
Material and Methods
One-dimensional dose
profiles of 5x5 mm² to 60x60 mm² photon beams (Varian TrueBeam, 10 MV FFF, SSD
= 90 cm, 10 cm depth in water) and common planar SRT dose distributions were
sampled with high resolution and fitted to interpolate data sets with arbitrary
sampling distances. The data sets were transformed by Discrete Fourier Transformation
and examined for aliasing effects using the amplitude spectrum. The resulting
Nyquist frequencies per field size or dose distribution were validated by
evaluating the energy densities of the data sets under the assumption that
99.95 %, 99.97 % or 99.99 % of the spectral energy density can be assigned to
the actual signal.
In addition, stereotactic VMAT plans were
measured with the SRS MapCHECK (Sun Nuclear Corp. Melbourne, FL, USA) at the
native sampling resolution (3.5 mm lat./long. and 2.49 mm diagonal), as well as
at the double sampling resolution (1.75 mm lat./long. and 2.49 mm diagonal),
which was achieved by merging two longitudinally shifted measurements. Both measured
dose distributions were compared to that of the treatment plans by γ index analysis
(1 mm, 1 %, TH 10%).
Results
The Nyquist frequencies
of static beams averaged over all methods suggest required sampling distances
of (2.2±0.8) mm for a 5 mm beam, (2.3±0.6) mm for a 10 mm beam, (2.5±0.6) mm
for a 20 mm beam, (3.3±0.9) mm for a 40 mm beam and (4.0±1.1) mm for a 60 mm
beam. The required sampling distance for the SRT treatment plans proved to be
(2.4 ±0.5) mm, i.e. slightly larger than the results of the smallest beam
segments due to beam accumulation.
The results of the γ index analysis
of the measurements with single and double detector density showed no
significant differences.
Conclusion
The Nyquist frequency of
small, static radiation fields suggests a required sampling distance upwards of
(2.2±0.8) mm. The required sampling distance of a detector array additionally increases
with the distance parameter of the commonly used γ index analysis
and signal perturbation effects, such as volume averaging (Poppe et al. 2007),
at the cost of sensitivity to errors. The theoretical analysis was validated by
comparing measurements with a detector array matching the Nyquist frequency
within uncertainty and repeated measurements with oversampling detector
density. Consequently, previously published recommendations of 2.5 mm
sampling distance for treatment verification measurements (Dempsey et al. 2005,
Poppe et al. 2007) could be confirmed for SRT cases by theoretical analysis.